Sometime in 2006, one of the ten days of the Ganesh Utsav, I was coming back home from work one night. The temple nearest to my house was filled up with the people who had come for the ganesh aarthi. I was walking nonchalantly towards my home when suddenly I felt a strong stinging "slap" on the back my neck. I winced in pain and God knows which part of my brain told me to duck into the nearest open gate but I did. And as I rushed into safety of God-knows-whose-home, I saw two youths speeding away on a motorbike. I was not sure whether it was an incident of eve teasing or what but as soon as they zoomed past me, I ran for my life into my house barely 50 meters away. Once I told my mom what happened, she, not being in shock that a victim faces, checked the spot where they "hit" me and told me matter-of-factly, It was your gold chain they were after. And true, the sting was that of a blunt blade which left a long thin scar at the nape of my neck. And my chain, well it was broken into two. The only reason why they did not get it was because, it had a ganesh pendant attached to it and as I had just walked past the temple where the aarathi was going on, I had, without realising, clutched the pendant and was humming along the aarathi.
In the same year, one of my colleagues returning from work late at night in a 7-seater auto, was robbed of all her gold ornaments and cash and ATM cards. She was a careful woman who dreaded other heinous crimes and got into such autos only if there was another female co-passenger... That fateful night, there was one. An accomplice. She blew chilli powder in this female's face and then the gang made off with the loot. She, to this day, considers herself lucky that it was just the money they were after.
Many such incidents come to our minds. The ones we have read in newspapers, heard from friends. And what is the first reaction that comes to our mind? Maaaaan, people OUGHT to be so careful while travelling at night. Its an unsafe world out there.
Circa 2009, Sydney - A couple of Indian students in Melbourne were mugged by druggies, junkies whoever. And the media cries "Racism"... Whhhhhaaat! And since then, each of the attacks gets undiluted publicity in the print and the press. Ozland is racist. People here are just so hung about themselves. Why cant the country do something to provide security to international student? Universities want money, they don't bother about the Indian students!!!
This kind of knee jerk reaction takes me by surprise. I am not, for a moment, condoning the attacks. Its bad that students who come here to study should face something like this. But when someone is robbed/raped in India while traveling late at night, its an unfortunate incident which could have been warded off if the victim was a bit more careful. But at the same time when something like this happens in a foreign land, we are all ready to scream at the top of our voices RACISM... What the hell do you mean when you react saying Indian students need security. Are you implying that all those Aussie students and people who got mugged deserved it? Why are you not reporting various mugging and robbery episodes that have seen Aussies, Chinese and other "westerners" hurt or even dead? Is their life of no value or consequence in comparison to an Indian's? Who is a racist here? And who isn't a racist? Just because the robbers in India are of the same skin tone, we are quick to rebuke the victim. And because the attackers here are not desis we cry foul? What kind of parameter is that?
Indian students in Australia are a workforce. Poor kids, my heart goes out to them at times. Working in Seven-11s at nights. Cleaning offices. Working their asses off in grocery stores and malls and all such places. The 20hrs per week work restrictions that student VISA imposes on them is an evil. They like to take their chances and not report all their work hours in fairness. The employers, well aware of this, take advantage of these kids. Again opportunism, not racism. Not unlike the Indian baniya who thinks nothing of employing under aged kids in his shops to lift heavy sacks of rice and wheat knowing too well, he is in too much need of money to complain.
These kids, the Aussie Indian students, work all inhuman hours till 2 or 3 in the nights. And when its time to come back home, the only cheap and economical option in the public transport. trains. Which, at that hour, are bereft of many people. Most of the passengers at this time are tired and overworked students or shady characters. Understandable, isn't it?
Would you consider it safe to ride an APSRTC bus at 3 a.m in Hyderabad? Is Mumbai local a safe ride at 2 am? No? Then why should the Sydney metro be any different? Lets use the thing we all refer to as common sense before making ridiculous assumptions about the country on the whole.
True, racism exists in bits and pieces in any foreign land. I would be one of the first to admit it. As a 9-month pregnant woman, I have had "chapters" of silent snobbery where people did not make way for me in the lifts/crowded trains and I would have to push through them with my big belly. And the very next instant, when a gori pregnant woman came on, there would be smiles and gushes and instant gaps. It used to make my heart cry. But the selected few people who did that, the memories they left have been overwritten by scores of others who made me feel comfortable and special in those trying days. So yeah, racism is present here, but this place is not racist. Yes, their condemnation of the Indian workforce, their contempt for the desis who have taken away "their jobs" is a racist trait. But then, Indian awe of the firangees is a racist thing too, isn't it?
So basically aren't we all the same?
A woman by birth, an Indian by heart and software engineer by chance, wife to a wonderful man & mother to an adorable little princess by destiny, a humorous wisecracker, avid reader, decent singer by choice. That in a nut-shell is me. Stay with me as I share with you my views on life.
Friday, June 19, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


11 comments:
Are we all the same - YES. For a change I agree wit what you say. Now go mark the date in your diary and tell this to your daughter when she grows up.
Wont ask the rhetorical Q if all is fine, but do say hi to your little one...
Very true .. excellent post
The media needs some masala to churn out .. and our MORONIC politicians are only too ready to take the bait and act 'stern' on the international arena.
Mugging is an (almost) universal feature. Our psuedo-patriotic media buffoons only report the attacks on India. Screw them.
btw..one point of disagreement : Mumbai is still safe at 2 am :)
Good to see some sense. Racism exists world over. Including in India. It's just that in India there are fewer races than perhaps the UK, US, Aus or Canada. Given the Indian history for discrimination based on caste, religion, region, language and gender, I am willing to safely bet that if there are more races in India, racism too will exist.
I would like to add to Suri's comment: Mumbai is not safe at 2 a.m. is you are travelling alone.
@Sandy: You are going to kill me one of these days with the shock therapy. The little one says a hi too :)
@Suri: Thanks suri... The mindless driveling by the Indian media is indeed in a bad taste. As one of the "local desi" pointed out, a lot many indians stay here in australia and have been happy, peaceful and successful in general. This kind of reporting sours their relationship with the local boys. But media, anywhere in the world, thrives on sensationalism. Be it so :(
@Pysch Babbler: Racism DOES exist in India. We are just used to the name "casteism". Even that is not accurate at times. Tell a bengali brahmin family to marry thier son/daughter off to a south indian brahmin and you shall know what I mean.
@Pysch Babbler/Suri: IMHO, Mumbai is NOT safe when you are a female and are alone at nights.
Argumentative India - We are unhappy if government acts and we are unhappy if they don't. Gotta luv the democracy! I think there is nothing wrong with raising concerns over attack on our brothers overseas. It may have been little too much but, that doesn't mean we should stop it all together. Remember what happened in East Africa?
Lived in Atlanta - the integrated city (read white and blacks together), sounds good on paper only reality is something else.
@Swraj: No grouses about the government being concerned about the attacks buddy. I mean, yes take it up by all means. IN THE RIGHT SPIRIT. Say Indian students are attacked and we are concerned. Thats fine. But what the hell is going on with pointing fingers and shouting RACISM at the drop of a hat. How many of those attackers were aussies mate? More often than not, its the lebanese (migrants themselves) who are into this. The suburbs where all these incidents have happened have been labelled shady suburbs for quite a while now. Before the Indian students episodes happened the largest victimised group was SENIOR AUSSIE CITIZENS in those suburbia. Why doesnt the Indian media highlight all those facts? Why is a skewed picture being shown all over the country? And do you really think its the concern for the students that is driving the media/government to do this? I really wonder if you are that naive still :)
@the Eternally Confused - To put things in perspective here, track the U.S.A /Canada /European media's news broadcast when dealing with their citizen's abroad. If one of their own sneezes, it's a breaking news! Folks getting attacked with petrol bombs would definitely qualify for some good coverage. So, let's sit back and minimize the bashing of our media/gov. for will need (let's say Sri Lanka??) them. I am sure Australians have their own justification but, to be fair, no one said Australia was racist, just the attacks were. May be the answer is for Australians to improve those shady areas or may be to investigate and put the perpetrators through the process of law.. what ever may be the outcome, it's very natural (and understandable) for Indians to watch out for Indians. We are all family ...a big, fat, dysfunctional family! :-)
(Reposted the comment as I forgot to proof read it!)
Yeah, then why dont we watch over our own brethren being torched in trains by our own brethren? And why cant these politics let the brahmin boys be? Is there one politician who will come out in open and say if a Brahmin lad from a poor family scores 95% in 12th and the dalit son of a MLA/Cabinet minister makes a total of 35%, which one of them deserves an reservation quota engg seat?
Bro, racism is much more rampant in India all times of the day. And WITH the blessings of the government. Here, at least, the government is trying to apprehend the criminals.
I am NOT for a moment saying, anywhere in post/comments, that the coverage per se is wrong. Its the attitude that comes forth in the coverage is wrong. Because some attacks happened they ARE labelling the place RACIST(not the attacks, mind you. Watch the coverage and you know what I am talking). They make it seem as if people here at waiting at the airports to torch all Indians. Reality is not that bad!
And cleaning out suburbs takes time. Can anyone yell and say clear out old basti and charminar area in Hyderabad? Or old walled portions of Amdavad? Will such "bold" people survive to see the light of the day in India?
We, the pot, are calling the kettle black here! And yes, we can. But lets not make such a show of it.
Here, people are acting on it unlike our own country where scores die for their caste and relegion each day and the vote-bank-greedy politics, lets them!
Post a Comment